Advertisement
Circumstantial planning

Circumstantial planning

A wedding, a career shift or an investment plan for your kids - each occasion throws up opportunities to derive tax benefits.

As you grow older, your financial needs change and so should your investment strategy. MONEY TODAY looks at the typical high points of your life and the ways you can minimise your tax outgo in these circumstances.

Marriage

There's one guest you definitely don't want to see at a wedding party, and no, we aren't talking of an old flame. Imagine, if you will, a tax collector standing behind the happy couple, taking his share of the cash gifts. Inconceivable, isn't it? A wedding is one of the few occasions when the authorities do not tax gifts of cash. Of course, the recipient will have to prove that the cash was a gift, so it might make it easier if money is given in the form of cheques or demand drafts.

Even after the actual ceremony, some of these benefits continue. Cash gifts from specified relatives are not taxed. What the couple should be aware of, however, is the clubbing provision. The money that a woman receives from her husband and parents-in-law is not taxed, but any income earned from investing this money is clubbed with the income of the giver. Similarly, the income from the money received from the wife would be clubbed with her income.

WHY YOU SHOULDN’T WITHDRAW YOUR PF (AN EXAMPLE)
  Age Monthly Contribution (Rs) Corpus At Age 60 (Rs)
Ajay 25 2,000 46.18 lakh
Bhushan 35 4,000 38.29 lakh
Chander 45 8,000 27.86 lakh
Bhushan and Chander withdrew their PF when they changed jobs at 35 and 45 years, respectively. Even though Bhushan's monthly contribution at 35 is double and Chander's at 45 is four times that of Ajay, their retirement corpus will not be as big.

It may seem easy to escape the clubbing provisions between husband and wife. A man can give a gift to his brother who can then pass it back to his sister-in-law. However, if such circular transactions are discovered, the exemption can be disallowed. As Delhi-based financial consultant Surya Bhatia says, "The law should be followed not just in letter, but in spirit."

If the income from the gifted money attracts clubbing, perhaps a husband could give a loan to his wife. Such loans are possible if the money is not used to generate income. "It all depends on the genuineness of the transaction. It is possible to take such loans for buying property," says Vikas Vasal, executive director, KPMG. If the money is invested, then the recipient will have to prove that it is a loan and the giver will have to charge a reasonable rate of interest on that loan. The giver will have to add the interest to his income for the year. Given the tax payable on that income and the problems of proving that the money was indeed a loan, it's a zero sum game.

Minor Problems

Cash Gifts From These Relatives Are Not Taxed As Income
• Spouse
• Parents
• Parents-in-law
• Own siblings (and their spouses)
• Siblings of spouse (and their spouses)
• Siblings of parent (and their spouses)
• All lineal ascendants or descendants (and their spouses)

Till a few years ago, you could invest in a long-term bond designed to mature when your child turned 18. In this way, you paid no tax, and by the time the investment matured, your child would be liable to pay tax on it. But this has changed. Today, the interest earned on term deposits and bonds is taxed in the year that it accrues even though the investor gets it on maturity.

This complicates the matter for the parents who want to invest in fixed deposits for thier children. The income earned from the investments of children below 18 years is clubbed with the income of the parent who earns more. So, opening fixed deposits in the name of minors makes little sense. What is practical, however, is to open a PPF account in the name of the child, as PPF income is not taxable at any stage (see page 36). The contribution to your own PPF account and that of the child cannot exceed the overall limit of Rs 70,000 a year. This is something Amritsar-based college professor Sandeep Kumar knows. He wants to open a PPF account in the name of his twoyear-old son because his own account is maturing in three years.

If you are willing to take a little risk, go for other tax-free options such as Ulips. The income from Ulips is not taxable. The income from traditional life insurance policies such as money-back plans and endowment policies is also tax-free, but the returns are niggardly compared with the other options. The long-term nature of Ulips makes them good investments for your children. It's best to choose a plan that can be continued by the child well into his adulthood.

Switching Careers

A rival company makes you an offer that you cannot refuse. You move with a higher salary, better designation, a corner office and all the perks. And you close the Provident Fund account you had with your earlier employer and start a new one. You repeat the process when you get an even better offer a few years down the line. Each time you wipe out your PF account, treat the money as some sort of windfall and don't think of investing it.

That can be a costly mistake. As the table shows, a slow and steady contribution to the PF account is very rewarding in the long term. If you keep adding small amounts and don't withdraw anything, then your PF can be the one and only debt investment in your financial plan. And that too, completely tax-free.

Grown-up Kids

Your grown-up child can help you save tax. The interest paid on the education loan for a child is fully deductible under Section 80E of the Income Tax Act. "Instead of saving for his education, take a loan and avail of the tax benefits," says Sudhir Kaushik, director of tax e-filing portal, Taxspanner. Besides, investments in the name of children over 18 years do not attract the clubbing provision.

Parents like Kumar could also consider investing in mutual funds in their children's name. Unlike fixed deposits, income from mutual funds is taxed only at the time of withdrawal. So, if you opt for an equity or a balanced mutual fund for over a year, the income will be tax-free because long-term gains are tax-exempt. If you invest in a debt mutual fund in the name of a 10-year-old child and the investment is redeemed after 10 years, the income will belong to the 20-year-old youth, not you.

Aged Parents

Your aged parents also give you an opportunity to save tax. Till 2007-8, the tax exemption under Section 80D for medical insurance was Rs 15,000 a year. Last year's budget raised this to Rs 30,000, provided that the additional Rs 15,000 was spent on the health cover taken for the senior citizen parent(s). In the highest tax slab, this translates into a saving of up to Rs 4,500 in tax. If you are staying with your parents in their house, you can pay them rent and claim HRA exemption. The rent, however, will be included in the income of the parent who owns it and (s)he will be taxed on it.

Case Studies

Atul Sharma with family

I. Atul Sharma, 38, Delhi

Works for a very small company that does not have a provident fund. He is the sole earning member of his family.

Income: Rs 50,000 per month

Current asset allocation: Invests heavily in equities, with an overwhelming 95% of his Section 80C investments going into ELSS funds.

Equities: 80 per cent, Debt: 20 per cent

His tax plan for 2008-9
Section 80C His investents (Rs) Our suggestion (Rs)
PPF 800 16,000
ELSS 93,000 60,000
Ulip 6,200 6,200
Insurance Nil 7,800
Pension plan Nil 10,000
Total 1,00,000 1,00,000

Comments:

  1. Sharma needs to have a debt cushion because his company does not offer provident fund.
  2. He should not go overboard in equities. His current asset allocation is already skewed towards equities.
  3. The Ulip is actually like a term plan with a Rs 10-lakh cover.
  4. We suggest another term plan of Rs 15 lakh for 25 years. It will cost only Rs 7,800 a year.
  5. He should invest a small sum for his retirement.

II. Sandeep Kumar, 34, Amritsar

Sandeep Kumar with children

He plans to open a PPF account in the name of his two-year-old son. He also invests in ELSS and insurance policies.

Income: Rs 25,000 per month

Current asset allocation: Considering his age, the equity exposure is quite low. A plot of land constitutes the bulk of his asset allocation.

Real Estate: 66 per cent, Debt: 28 per cent, Equities: 6 per cent.

His tax plan for 2008-9
Section 80C His plan (Rs) Our suggestion (Rs)
PF/PPF 43,000 18,000
ELSS 12,000 37,000
Fixed deposits Nil Nil
Insurance 28,500 28,500
Pension plan Nil Nil
Total 83,500 83,500

Comments:

  1. Kumar has a Rs-1,000 SIP in the Sundaram BNP Pribas Tax saver. He should invest more in ELSS funds.
  2. He already has a good debt cushion. No point in adding to it at this stage by opening a PPF account in his son's name.
  3. Traditional insurance plans cover him for Rs 5.5 lakh. The high premium of Rs 28,500 prevents other investments.
  4. He should consider a term plan to raise his insurance cover.
  5. A Rs 10 lakh cover for 30 years will cost Rs 4,500 a year.