"Valuations at 42x/35x FY26/27 P/E leave little room for error," added Citi.
Jefferies maintained an underperform stance on the stock with a price target of Rs 950.
Q1 was tough for the firm as exports outlook worsened by weak macro and rising US-India tariffs. However, ramp-up of large Indian guns order to begin from Q4, which is a positive trigger, said Jefferies.
FY26–28E EPS estimates are 9–14% below Street consensus, it added.
In its management commentary, the firm said exports to the US were 200 million amounting to 10% of the company's revenue.
It expects political resolution to tariff issues “sooner than later". Q1 performance was impacted by weakness in Europe, US, and sector-specific slowdowns.
Meanwhile, Bharat Forge stock slipped 3.1% to Rs 1103 on BSE. Market cap of the firm stood at Rs 53,082 crore. Total 0.27 lakh shares of the firm changed hands amounting to a turnover of Rs 2.99 crore.
The stock fell to a 52-week low of Rs 919.10 on February 28, 2025 and rose to a 52 week high of Rs 1654.10 on August 9, 2024.
Bharat Forge logged a 62.60% rise in consolidated net profit to Rs 283.87 crore in Q1 FY25 against Rs 174.58 crore posted in Q1 of FY25.
However, revenue from operations fell 4.80% YoY to Rs 3,908.75 crore in the quarter ended 30 June 2025. Profit before tax (PBT) stood at Rs 410.99 crore in Q1 FY26, rising 37.20% from Rs 299.54 crore reported in the corresponding period a year ago.
Motilal Oswal sees a 7% downside in the stock to Rs 1,060 in a year. It has a neutral stance on stock.
"Considering the weak 1Q performance and a weak outlook for most of its key segments, we have lowered our FY26/FY27 EPS estimates by 12%/15%. Management has noted that FY26 is likely to be challenging amid tariff-led uncertainties and changes in emission regulation in North America. Given these factors, the stock at 44x/34.4x FY26E/FY27E consolidated EPS appears fairly valued," said MOSL.
Brokerage Nuvama maintained its hold stance after Q1 earnings.
Q1FY26 standalone revenue fell 10% YoY to Rs 2100 crore, below estimate on the back of lower-than-expected export revenue.
EBITDA fell 13% to Rs 570 crore, below estimate on the back of a revenue miss and tariff impact of Rs 14 crore.
The brokerage expressed concerns on the business outlook of the firm.
"Core segments such as commercial vehicles and global construction equipment/tractors are likely to be weak, limiting standalone revenue/EBITDA CAGR at 7%/6% over FY25–28E. Moreover, we reckon subsidiaries shall stay in losses. Retain ‘HOLD’ with a TP of INR1,280 (earlier INR1,230) based on 35x/15x Sep-27E (earlier Mar-27E) EV/EBITDA for defence/remaining businesses," said Nuvama.