scorecardresearch
Where is Citibank headed in India?

Where is Citibank headed in India?

The world's largest bank is gasping for breath. Will it now cut back operations globally to put its house back in order, or will it expand in India and China to offset its losses elsewhere?

He’s just finished a meeting with the promoter of a large Indian corporation who wants to raise half a billion dollars and is sitting in his 5th-floor office in Mumbai’s Bandra-Kurla commercial complex. “Business is flowing in for us,” says Sanjay Nayar, the dapper 46-year-old CEO of Citigroup’s Indian operations and Area Head for Bangladesh, Nepal and Sri Lanka.

Sanjay Nayar, CEO, Citi India
Sanjay Nayar, CEO, Citi India
The spacious room has a busy air about it and is cluttered with dozens of coffee table books but that doesn’t seem to bother Nayar, who is squeezing in meeting after meeting into his busy day. A client here, a colleague there, a couple of exit interviews…

Nayar’s just back from a meeting with Citigroup’s global CEO, Vikram Pandit in Citi’s New York headquarters, where things are far more down-tempo than they are here in India. There Pandit, 51, who took charge at the bank in December 2007, is grappling with the onerous task of restructuring Citi’s global balance sheet.

The biggest bank in the US has been hit hard by the subprime crisis with losses and writedowns mounting close to $50 billion since mid-2007. What’s scaring Citibankers in India and elsewhere is Pandit’s declaration that he wants to sell assets worth $400 billion over the next three years. Recently, the bank sold its German banking operations for $7.7 billion to France’s Crédit Mutuel and speculation is rife about a possible offloading of Citi’s non-core assets in Japan.

Back in India, Nayar, too, has his plate full, although Citi’s Indian operations are far better off than what its global situation looks like. Still, his troubles are irksome. Recently, three key Citi executives left the bank—Rajesh Mayani, Director of institutional sales, Ratnesh Kumar, head of research and Narayan Mulchandani, director (sales), in Hong Kong, signed up with a local Indian stockbroking firm, Anand Rathi Securities. Besides these, two others, Anil Gudibande, director and Ashish Pitale, director, global banking, moved to AIG Private Equity and Deutsche Bank, respectively.

 Nayar, a 23-year Citi veteran, is concerned about these exits. “I’m never happy about losing people. I take people exits very seriously,” says Nayar, throwing his hands up in despair. Adds Citi’s HRD head Ian Gore, downplaying the recent attrition a bit: “Citi has always been a natural target for industry to source talent.”

Keeping his flock together is quite evidently high priority for Nayar because stability of Citi’s Indian business is vital for the bank’s global operations as well. In the next month or so, Pandit is expected to visit India for the first time since he took charge at the bank. Pandit’s predecessor, Chuck Prince, who visited India in March 2007, had famously called India the bank’s “single-biggest driver of growth” for the group’s international operations.

As Nayar prepares for his boss’s visit, Citi also has to deal with the vexing question of how it deals with its rapidly growing operations in emerging markets like India, which are in sharp contrast with what is happening in the developed markets.

One scenario, often speculated in the market, is that Citi has little choice but to scale down Indian operations to tide over the crisis by trimming costs. Another scenario could be to go in the opposite direction and step on the gas in the faster growing emerging markets like India, China, Mexico and Brazil.

For now, it isn’t very clear which option the Citigroup’s management will adopt. That sort of uncertainty has Citi India’s 22,000 employees more than a little worried about their future. A proposal to link their annual bonuses with the overall global performance of the bank is also a hot topic of discussion among them. Says Gore: “We have ensured that employees here know exactly what’s happening in the organisation and also the strategy to properly position ourselves.”

Citi’s focus on emerging markets like the Indian one has been sharpened by Pandit’s recent restructuring of the reporting arrangements, which have changed from reporting on the basis of business-specific heads to region-specific heads. Nayar, for instance, now works closely with Ajay Banga, head of Asia Pacific, including Japan.

The new structure with four geographic heads is aimed at making Citigroup a client-focussed organisation. “We are in the midst of articulating a new strategy for Asia,” says Nayar.

Putting at rest all market speculations, he says: “India is one of the priority markets and it continues to stay so.” Nayar, who has been heading Citi in India since October 2002, has had a very stable top management team for the past five years.

Yet, there have been quite a few changes recently. P. S. Jayakumar, who headed consumer banking since 2005, has now moved to Hong Kong and N. Rajashekaran, who has replaced him, comes with stints at Bank of America and ABN AMRO.

N. Rajashekaran, Country Business Manager, Citibank (Global Consumer Group) India
N. Rajashekaran, Country Business Manager, Citibank (Global Consumer Group) India
Nayar says Citi India faces no problems in attracting talent. “There’s very good talent wanting to come back to us,” he says, citing some recent hires like Ravi Lambah as managing director ( technology, media and telecom Group) who came from Credit Suisse, Nalin Nayyar, managing director (Investment Banking) who left Lehman Bros., and Sameer Nath, who has moved back from Citi US as director (M&A).

Likewise, Citifinancial, an NBFC that used to offer mortgage and unsecured lending products, which is restructuring its product mix, has a new boss, Rahul Soota. “People with the experience of working in sophisticated and developed markets are showing an increased interest in relocating to emerging markets like India,” says Pramit Jhaveri, Citi India’s head of investment banking.

 CITI India’s action plan

Citibank has identified five growth drivers in India.

Business Segment Initiative

Wealth Management Major focus on wealth management, both at the bank and in the NBFC Citifinancial from mortgages and unsecured loans. Plans to target all segments—from mass-affluent to ultra high net worth individuals.

SME Plans to leverage its SME portfolio for consumer banking products like mortgages, personal loans and other products.

Trade Finance Trade finance is a stable business at a time when liquidity in the system is drying up. Rising trade volumes between India and the world offers immense scope for growth.

Cards Debit and credit cards have been a focus area for Citigroup globally. The strategy here is to look for new payments solutions in credit cards and also enter the mobile payments space.

Transaction Banking This has been identified as one of the four distinctive product platforms globally. This is a stable business and the group wants to launch innovative products under this business.


It’s not surprising why. India is right at the top of Citi’s emerging markets business in terms of growth, posting an awe-inspiring 100 per cent jump in profits for the year 2007-08. However, in the same period, Citifinancial reported a drop in its net profit from Rs 222 crore in 2006-07 to Rs 12 crore in 2007-08.

Ian Gore, Head of HRD, Citibank India
Ian Gore, Head of HRD, Citibank India
There are problems with the group’s lending portfolio that even Nayar admits, but adds that these problems are being fixed. In the last 3-4 years, like most other banks, Citi has built a huge book and there is every possibility of the bank taking a very sizeable knock under this segment.

“We are not exiting the lending business whether it is mortgages or unsecured loans,” says Nayar. He has a clear action plan ready for Citifinancial, which suffered in the past. Income rose by 30 per cent to Rs 1,820 crore but profitability, as noted earlier, slipped to Rs 12 crore in 2007-08 from a high of Rs 222 crore last year due to higher delinquencies in the unsecured lending business. Nayar says he’s going to try and convert Citifinancial into a one-stop finance company where an emerging middle-class person can go and get serviced for all his financial needs except for deposits.

Pramit Jhaveri Head, Investment Banking Citibank India
Pramit Jhaveri Head, Investment Banking Citibank India
In consumer banking, credit cards continue to be the focus despite higher delinquencies in the business, which resulted in a higher non-performing asset ratio that rose from 1.02 per cent in 2006-07 to 1.23 per cent in 2007-08. Says consumer banking head Rajashekaran: “We continue to build on our comprehensive cards portfolio and are taking it to the next level by leveraging and embedding technology for multiple uses.” Nayar, however, says that the bank has to be very careful of how it sources credit cards and who it does business with. Adds T. R. Ramachandran, who heads retail banking: “Our focus is on the mass-affluent segment and on broadbasing customer acquisition, universal banking, wealth management and more effective leveraging of our SME portfolio.”

 Under watch

Citibank is also present in some businesses that aren’t central to its plans anymore.

Mortgages and Unsecured Loans Mortgages are a stable, but low-yielding business. The strategy is to move cautiously in this niche.

Retail Broking Citi has entered this business only recently. The turmoil in the stock markets may affect its plans.

Custodial Services This business, which is a key part of transaction banking, is getting impacted due to FIIs pulling out of Indian bourses.

Investment Banking Fewer IPOs and deals make this business unattractive as of now. Globally, Citi is cutting 10 per cent of its 65,000-strong work force in I-banking.

Treasury The not-so-good experience of mid-sized companies in the forex derivatives space with banks in India places a question mark over this business.

Source: BT Research


V. Shrikanth MD (Head of Fixed Income, and Citibank Commodities), Global Consumer Group India
V. Shrikanth MD (Head of Fixed Income, and Citibank Commodities), Global Consumer Group India
Meanwhile, globally, Pandit has identified transaction banking as one of the four top priority areas as it contributes 8-10 per cent of the global revenues. While custody banking, where they act as a custodian for housing foreign investors’ shares, will be hit due to foreign institutional investors (FIIs) pulling out of a weak stock market, trade and cash management businesses are still on an upswing.

“We have expanded the team and added 20 per cent more people since the beginning of the year and also substantially increased the investments in technology,” says Ashish Bajaj, Head, Transactional Banking. In fact, the transaction banking team is ready with a strategy to double its business over the next three years. Says V. Srikanth , Managing Director (Head of Fixed Income, Forex and Commodities ): “Sales and trading in forex and fixed income continue to be our key growth driver.”

 
Click here to enlarge
But at the time of writing, speculation was rife over whether Citi would be selling its 11.74 per cent stake in Indian housing finance major HDFC. Nayar stoutly refutes it, though. “It’s one of the best principal stakes we have made in HDFC Ltd. This is the only way a firm like ours is able to enjoy the uptick in India’s financial services sector. We are very much embedded into that stake,” says Nayar.

Citigroups Pandit: Onerous task of restructuring Citis global balance sheet
Citigroups Pandit: Onerous task of restructuring Citis global balance sheet
Still, Citigroup is at a critical juncture, globally, and anything could happen, particularly when Pandit has resolved to dispose of assets worth $400 billion in the next three years. “But”, says Nayar, “We have never had any constraints placed on us from New York on capital or resources.” But rival bankers say if things deteriorate globally for the bank, there could be pressure on the Indian operation to get rid of non-core assets as is being done elsewhere.

The HDFC stake, Citi’s business process outsourcing outfit, and its infrastructure technology company, Citco, are the ones that could top the list. But anything can happen given Pandit’s plan to sell $400 billion worth of assets in the next three years. Before Pandit’s proposed visit to India, Nayar plans to take a break and go trekking in Ladakh. But as he walks the highaltitude terrain, will his mind be free of what’s happening in New York and what that could mean for Citi’s Indian business?